Understanding SQL's Declarative Syntax and Semantic Ordering

October 11, 2024 (3w ago)

Declarative Syntax in SQL

In SQL, declarative syntax allows users to focus on what data they want to retrieve rather than how to retrieve it. This approach abstracts away the complexity of data retrieval, allowing the DBMS (Database Management System) to handle the underlying operations efficiently. Declarative syntax describes the intended result without specifying the steps required to achieve it. This makes SQL intuitive and accessible to those without a deep understanding of database processing internals.

SQL Syntactic Order vs. Semantic Order

SQL has a specific syntax order, which dictates how queries are written. However, the actual evaluation order of these clauses (semantic order) is different. This difference can make it challenging to read and interpret SQL queries, as the syntactic order doesn't always align with the way the query is executed internally.

Example: Syntactic Order

Consider the following SQL query:

-- Syntactic Order in SQL
SELECT r.d, sum(r.e) AS s, rank() OVER (order BY r.d)
FROM r JOIN s USING (id)
WHERE r.c < 15
GROUP BY r.d
HAVING sum(r.e) > 3
ORDER BY r.d

In the above example, the query's syntactic order is designed to specify the final structure and constraints of the data. However, this order does not reflect the actual processing order. Here, syntactic order refers to how SQL clauses must be written in SQL syntax, following the order: SELECT, FROM, WHERE, GROUP BY, HAVING, ORDER BY.

Semantic Order

The DBMS processes the query in a different sequence known as the semantic (evaluation) order. The semantic order for the query above would be:

  1. Join Tables (FROM): Start by joining tables r and s based on their shared id column.
  2. Apply Initial Filter (WHERE): Filter rows from the joined tables where r.c < 15.
  3. Group Rows (GROUP BY): Group the filtered data by column d.
  4. Aggregate and Filter Groups (HAVING): After grouping, apply the condition sum(r.e) > 3 to filter groups.
  5. Sort Results (ORDER BY): Sort the remaining groups by column d.
  6. Select and Project (SELECT): Finally, select and display columns, including d, aggregate s, and calculate rank.

The semantic order is the actual sequence in which operations are executed by the DBMS, which may differ from the syntax order. Understanding this order is crucial for writing effective SQL queries, as it helps anticipate the result set at each stage.

Pipe Syntax: Aligning Syntax with Evaluation Order

To improve readability, pipe syntax offers a structure that directly aligns with the semantic order. In pipe syntax, the query is written to match the actual processing sequence, making it easier to follow. Here’s how the query looks in pipe syntax:

-- Pipe Syntax Example
FROM r JOIN s USING (id)
|> WHERE r.c < 15
|> AGGREGATE sum(r.e) AS s GROUP BY r.d
|> WHERE s > 3
|> ORDER BY d
|> SELECT d, s, rank() OVER (order BY d)

In this approach, each step in the query is processed in the order it is written:

  1. Join the tables first.
  2. Filter the data with WHERE.
  3. Aggregate the data with GROUP BY and compute sums.
  4. Apply a second filter after aggregation.
  5. Sort the data.
  6. Select the final projection.

Pipe syntax offers a clear advantage by matching syntax with semantic order, making complex queries more understandable.

Why Declarative Syntax Matters

Declarative syntax in SQL provides several benefits:

Pipe syntax and similar approaches enhance these benefits by offering greater readability and alignment between syntax and evaluation, which is particularly useful for new SQL users and complex query building.

Summary

SQL's declarative syntax is a powerful tool for data retrieval, focusing on the "what" rather than the "how." By understanding the difference between syntactic and semantic order, and leveraging alternatives like pipe syntax, you can write more effective, readable, and maintainable SQL queries.

LinkedIn